Daily Life Lessons from Rabbi Heschel
Year 4 Day 226
“Left alone, the soul is subject to caprice. Yet there is power in the deed that purifies desires. It is the act, life itself, that educates the will. The good motive comes into being while doing the good.” (God in Search of Man pg. 405)
I have been captivated by the ideas in these 4 sentences, hence spending 3 days on them! The last two sentences give us the rationale for “the deed”, “the act”. While we have stressed education, ‘morality’, different political and religious agendas, etc, Jewish wisdom from the Torah, from the Bible, stresses “the act” as a way that “educates the will”. It is apparent from Jewish ‘history’ that “the will” has a mind of its own and unless and until it comes under the power of the soul, unless it is subjected to “the deed”, “the will” continues to lead us around according to our whims and wishes, it keeps us “subject to caprice”. There is such power in immersing ourselves in our foundational spiritual text-the Bible-because we learn about “life itself”, we learn how difficult it is to live according to our “will” and live well, be happy, be human.
Listening to the ‘leaders’ of the free world these days is proof of the capriciousness that abounds precisely because these ‘good christian folk’ want to control and make everyone live according to to their “will”, not God’s will! They are not interested in “purifying desires”, they are only interested in having everyone serve their desires, they are only interested in getting away with as much as they can and, of course, being as cruel as they can while enslaving the rest of us to serve their capriciousness. For this sect of We the People, there is nothing, no “act” that “educates the will” because their will continually overpowers God’s will according to the Gospels, the descriptions of Jesus’ actions, etc. It certainly goes against what the Torah, the Bible teaches us-Lutnick, Bessent, Wytkoff, et al. For people like Smotrich, Netanyahu as well they continue to stonewall the truth above that “it is the act, life itself, that educates the will” because, like their good buddies in the US, Saudi Arabia, Hungary, Russia, etc, they don’t want their will to be in line with the Divine Will; this would mean they would have to follow a code that eschews cruelty, power for its own sake, grifting, lying, cheating, stealing, murdering- all of the ways they love to gain and hold power! How dare one ask these ‘fine upstanding gentlemen’ who are running these countries to give up what is near and dear to their hearts!
It is way past time for We the People, in what is left of this month of Elul, in these 23 days prior to Yom Kippur, to stop our need to live by our intentions, to wait for the purity of motive to take an action, to worry about what is in our hearts. FUCK THAT! “The good motive comes into being while doing the good”! This is the foundation of Living Jewishly, I believe. Take the next right action no matter how you think or feel has been my motto since my time in Prison. We the People are not judged by God, by self, by another for thoughts, for motives, only by actions. As the first sentence above states, “left alone…” Actions are the greatest companion for our souls, they shape and mold us, be they good or not good actions, every one we take either moves us closer or farther away from the goal to be human. This is one of the hardest things for most people to believe, to understand, to live into. On both ends of the religious, political, and emotional spectrums, the belief is in being ‘pure’, purity of motives, actions, beliefs, etc. Purity here is a substitute for certainty, be it the far right, the far left of these spectrums, We the People who are on them believe in their righteousness because of their certainty they are right, their way is the only way. Yet, we are taught there are 70 faces to the Bible, 70 ways to understand and live into the text, there are numerous interpretations of the New Testament, so, isn’t it a fallacy for We the People to demand purity from another, to state unequivocally that we are 100% sure ‘my way is the only way’? Yet, too many of We the People are so spiritually bankrupt, spiritually immature, spiritually uneducated that we seek certainty to cover our fears, to give us respite from facing life on life’s terms, from doing the next right action no matter what, from being responsible and doing the TShuvah we need to do, right here, right now.
This is the great challenge of these words, of this period of time: Do the next right action no matter what and stay out of the results. We the People are not to be concerned with how we are received when doing our TShuvah, we are not to be concerned if the other person(s) is so stuck that they cannot reconcile, they are so full of shit they think they are better than God who tells us at the beginning of the Kol Nidre Service: “Salachti, KidVorecha”, “I forgive as you have spoken”! God forgives but those great ‘progressive people’ who care for the underdog can be like stone to someone else and be fine with this contradiction even as they sit in Synagogue on Yom Kippur! Talk about self-deception! The same is, of course, true for the Far Right with their Tzitzis flying all around and killing people in the West Bank, Gaza for the ‘sport’ of it, not because God commanded it!
I have continued to “take the next right action” and do the TShuvah I need to each year since 1987 and my life is richer and more meaningful. I don’t know everyone I have harmed and all the ways I have screwed up because what one person found amazing, another finds disgusting-I only know that the actions I take are what I believe to be the best in the moment, they are always meant to help another person see the truth, and to serve them and the Ineffable One, even when I screw it up-the actions I take are in line with serving the Divine and the errors are mine, capriciousness is all me. It is hard to live this type of examined life and, as Socrates says: “an unexamined life is not worth living”. God Bless and stay safe, Rabbi Mark