Daily Life Lessons from Rabbi Heschel
Year 4 Day 217
“Purity of motivation is the goal; constancy of action is the way. It is useless endeavor to fight the ego in the open; like a wounded hydra, it produces two heads for every one cut off. We must not indulge in self-scrutinization; we must not concentrate upon the problem of egocentricity. The way to purify the self is to avoid dwelling upon the self and to concentrate upon the task.” (God in Search of Man pg. 404)
What I am hearing Rabbi Heschel say to us this morning, in the words above, is that the “ego” is the Yetzer HaRa, it is the ‘evil/earthly/animal’ inclination that every human being has. It is a “useless endeavor” to fight this inclination, our egos that are out of proper measure, that are false. The self protective shell around our egos, bolstered by the rational mind and its supreme ability to rationalize behaviors and/or blame another for their own shortcomings (this was happening before Goebbels, he only spoke about it out loud), will never allow itself to ‘lose’ a battle. Immersing ourselves in the teaching above allows us to see to “fight the ego”, to “indulge in self-scrutinization”, to “concentrate upon the problem of egocentricity”, “dwelling on the self” only strengthens the false “ego”, Look at how Trump and Bibi get more popular among their ‘base’ every time some one seeks to speak the truth about their false, outsized, evil “egocentricity”; isn’t it a wonder when their actions are subject to “scrutinization” they have a ready-made answer, someone else to blame and their people lap it up like trained seals! Sucking up to these assholes is the shame that We the People must own up to and bear during this month of Elul and do our TShuvah, change our ways and repair the damage we have wrought as well as the damage that has been wrought by their “ego” and our inability “to concentrate upon the task”!
The issue is not just our political chaos, it is the inner chaos that We the People are experiencing in this moment, as we have throughout history. When did the Israelites find moments that were not filled with inner chaos? After they crossed the Red Sea, after they received “the Word”, “the 10 Sayings” at Mount Sinai, when David was King for a minute or two, ie only after their encounters with something greater than themselves, with the Spirit of the Universe which is both within us and outside of us. While “purity of motivation is the goal”, what is more important, in my opinion and experience, is “constancy of action is the way”. Alcoholics Anonymous borrowed “act your way into right thinking” from the Bible. Nowhere in the Bible are our feelings of utmost importance, nowhere in the Bible is the inner motivation demanded, only “constancy of action”, only “concentrate upon the task” is stressed over and over again. Yet, We the People continue to fall prey to the snake-oil salesmen/women who are preaching ‘the holy gospel’ according to their “wounded hydra”, according to the “two heads” the “ego” produces within each of us. In the words of Pete Seeger: “When will we ever learn?”
The sycophants on display at Trumps Cabinet Meeting are despicable! The grifters, the liars, the ‘personalities’ at FOX UNNEWS are desecrators of God’s Name, the lap dogs/trained seals of the Republican Party in Congress are the soldiers of Satan, the ‘good christian preachers’ who propagate the lies of the ‘prosperity gospel’, who call Trump the messiah, sent by Jesus, are the Money-Changers in the Temple, the spreaders of Senseless Hatred. Yet, We the People, or at least enough of us, continue to watch and listen to their “egocentricity”, their “dwelling upon the self” with awe, reverence and lining up to take up their guns, their knives and fight the Capital Police, the DC Metro Police, the citizens of these United States in direct violation of the Constitution while John Roberts and his Court of Jesters applaud and back up the tearing up of the very Constitution that all of them FALSELY SWORE TO PROTECT!
We the People are being called to do the task whether our motivation is pure, whether we will do it ‘perfectly’ or not, whether we have our own agenda in mind, DO THE NEXT RIGHT THING! We are in the month of retrospection and repair precisely because we failed to in some cases “concentrate on the task”. Many of We the People have failed to engage in “constancy of action” because we adopt the societal lies and attitudes of ‘if it isn’t perfect, it isn’t worth anything’, ‘if my motives aren’t pure, then it is bullshit’, ‘who am I to tell another person they are wrong’ and other such poppycock. In the Bible, we are told to “rebuke the people” and “don’t carry sin because of him/her/them”. This is not a suggestion, it is a command found in Leviticus 19:17, meaning that every time we are “standing idly by the blood of our neighbor”, we are carrying the sin of our inaction. Every time we resist telling someone they are acting inappropriately, we are carrying the sin of our inaction. Every time we are afraid to speak truth to power, afraid of the retribution, we are carrying the sin of our inaction. Hence- “constancy of action”, “dwell upon the task” are the only pathways to wholeness, to holiness, to moving forward and to separating ourselves, L’Havdeel,(aka Havdalah), from the lethargy and the urge to “run after the majority to do evil” which is another prohibition.
I have been guilty of having my ego out of proper measure. I am guilty of staying silent at times. I am guilty of frustration at being powerless to effect change, being powerless at not having a platform to speak and teach from and being sad that I don’t. I also am continuing to write and publish, I am continuing to reach out to speak, preach, teach. I am continuing to fight the lethargy of institutional life and stand up for what is true, correct and right. I continue to “dwell upon the task” and life has meaning and purpose because I do. God Bless and stay safe, Rabbi Mark