Daily Life Lessons from Rabbi Heschel
Year 2 Day 111
“The power to make distinctions is a primary operation of intelligence. We distinguish between white and black, beautiful and ugly, pleasant and unpleasant, gain and loss, good and evil, right and wrong. The fate of mankind depends upon the realization that the distinction between good and evil, right and wrong, is superior to all other distinctions. As long as such realization is lacking, pleasantness in alliance with evil will be preferred to unpleasantness in alliance with good. To teach humanity the primacy of that distinction is of the essence to the Biblical message.”(God in Search of Man pg.372)
We have never been great at the realization of the second sentence above. Human Beings continue to seek out ways to destroy their ‘enemies’ while thriving themselves and it always results in tragedy. This is true since the beginning: Cain did not thrive after killing his brother, the Israelites became slaves, free people, then lost their land, we do not hear of the Assyrians, the Babylonians, Romans, Greeks of antiquity except in history. What has saved humankind, I believe, is that the messages of the Prophets, the messages of God through Moses has survived and, at times, thrived. No matter how close we come to annihilating ourselves, we have managed so far to be saved by their messages of return, of hope and realizing the “distinction between good and evil, right and wrong, is superior to all other distinctions”. We faced this 90 years ago with the election of Adolf Hitler in Germany and it took us 6-9 years to stand up to him and his Nazi collaborators, ensuring the buildup of the German Army and Concentration Camps and 12 years to defeat the Axis Powers and save the remnant of Jews, Gypsies, LGBTQ, and resisters from their death camps.
We can see how “pleasantness in alliance with evil” is being preferred today as it was then. In the USA, we hear about Christian Nation, America First, we hear about the ‘dreaded immigrants at our Southern border’, we don’t hear about the horror and consequences for the murder of Jamil Koshoggi, the consequences of the Saudi’s who attacked our country on 9/11, we hear words of praise and defense for the leaders of the Confederate Army and anger as well as disdain when these traitors’ statues are removed. We hear about bans on teaching the true history of slavery in this country, we hear anger and protests against Jews such as “Jews will not replace us” and we hear about using Congressional hearings to attack and weaponize government against the enemies of the Freedom Caucus, the enemies of the MAGA crowd and the silent acquiescence of other Republicans to these attacks, to these protests, to these bans. The people at the extremes have absolutely let go of any and all capacity to not only distinguish between good and evil, they have completely prefer the alliance of “unpleasantness with evil”. They can no longer distinguish one from the other-this is true no matter which extreme one is on, their pleasantness with evil is a prerequisite for their extreme positions because this position doesn’t allow for any doubts or questioning. The people who, I believe, Rabbi Heschel is speaking to us is everyone else. And, I am sad to say, we seem to be failing in our duty, our need, for humanity to remain humane, for power and greed to not rule us, to stop buying the lie of powerless and voiceless. The fact that the Bible has survived these 2500+ years, the fact that it is still the foundational basis of western morality, the foundational basis of freedom, is proof that we are not powerless nor voiceless in this war against being human that has always been waged by the rich, the powerful, the ruling classes against the rest of us.
We, the People, in order to form a “more perfect union” have to live into this realization that the distinction between right and wrong, good and evil is the primary distinction we have to make, each and every day, in each and every action we take. History, personal and global, has taught us that we have to make this distinction before taking an action, before deciding to go along to get along, before running after the majority to do evil, before deciding our fears are going to override the courage and knowledge of our souls/higher Consciousness. While we may not all be Mensa people, most of us, I believe and others disagree with me, learn to make the distinctions between good and evil, between right and wrong; most of us can hear the call of our souls and allow this call to lead us to do the next right thing. We can only do this when we are ready to fight for what is right, fight against evil, end our indifference to evil, stop taking our freedoms and way of living for granted. We have to tune our ears to God’s frequency instead of tuning into the “I will save you” frequency, instead of the “they are out to get us frequency”, etc.
This is one of the major changes we make in recovery. We stop following the “k-fuck” radio station that has been playing forever in our heads and we tune into hearing the call of our inner lives, the call of a trusted friend, a sponsor, a spiritual guide to help us distinguish between right and wrong actions, between what is good and what is evil both in the moment and for the long term. We use another person because we are humble enough to know that no matter how long we have in recovery, the ability to lie to ourselves, the ability to become willfully blind, never leaves us. After having not made the right decision for so long, this change becomes part of our foundation and living principles in our recovery. While difficult, this distinction is what our survival as human beings able to make free-will moral choices depends on. God Bless and stay safe, Rabbi Mark